Books of Magic
Is Harry Potter a copy-cat?
He is a loner wearing spectacles and a black hair. Because his family
doesn't understand him he is drifting around on his own. One day he
meets some strange people that asks whether he believes in magic. He
is told that he has the potential to become the greatest human wizard.
This is the beginning of the comic series Books of Magic that was first
published in the US in 1990. (It is sometimes being published in Denmark,
usually under the title "Magic Fantasy"). The series describes Tim's
adventures among wizards of all kinds, both good and evil. He slowly
learns to master spells, but in the mean time he realizes that he is not
just another wizard, but has been chosen by the higher powers to fight
the evil.
Now, before you say cheep imitation you ought to look at the copyright
notice. That's right the first story featuring Timothy Hunter was
published by DC Comics in 1990. Since then more than 75 issues have
followed. He is, in other words, quite a bit older than the world famous
Harry Potter, even though the stories share a remarkably number of
simmilarities. In that way it is interesting to ask wether Tim Hunter
was a model for Harry Potter. Did JKR know about Timothy Hunter? Is it
a unique coinsidence that the stories share not only a similar universe,
but also a similar main character? I don't know, and because DC Comics
is a part of the Warner-business we will definitely not see a lawsuit.
But back then, who cared about the univers of Tim Hunter? Who took it
seriously when you talked about the magic universe, the owl, the
spells? And it's not that the series is poor, it is actually really
good. Not only the artistics, but the story itself is much more complex
than a great many books. For instance, Tim's relationship to magic is
much less clarified and more sophisticated than in the world of Harry
Potter. Tim doesn't use magic like Harry when he waves the wand, plays
Quidditch or travels by flo powder. And the school is not just a wierd
British bordingschool where the stairs and pictures are moving. In Tim's
world the training takes place in a parallel universe that seems like a
dream, where only fragments make sense - until the puzzle, slowly, is put
together and it turns out that Tim has to face evil itself.
|